Swan BitcoinHome

Ten Million Bitcoiners: The Intransigent Minority

Posted 2/21/20 by Cory Klippsten

Not too many years from now, the number of Bitcoiners in the United States of America will cross ten million.  When we hit that milestone, it’s game over: Bitcoin wins.

My favorite writer and thinker, Nassim Nicholas Taleb, wrote about “the intran­si­gent minority” in his book Skin in the Game.  Here’s the concept at work: almost every packaged food product for sale in the U.S. has a tiny U inside a circle printed outside.  Very few U.S. residents require the kosher certi­fi­ca­tion indicated by that U, but it’s easier for food compa­nies not to have to make two separate lines for every product, so they gener­ally make every­thing kosher.  The rule, per Taleb: “A Kosher eater will never eat nonkosher food, but a nonkosher eater isn’t banned from eating kosher.”

For most observed complex systems, the minority contin­gent required to flip a popula­tion to comply with their intran­si­gent view is in the 3 – 4% range. With a U.S. popula­tion of 325 million, 3% is 10 million.

For most observed complex systems, the minority contin­gent required to flip a popula­tion to comply with their intran­si­gent view is in the 3 – 4% range.  With a U.S. popula­tion of 325 million, 3% is 10 million.

A fintech fund that’s been in the Bitcoin space since 2012 recently ran intense analysis resulting in the best estimate I’ve seen for Bitcoin owner­ship.  Just 7 million people globally are storing $100 of value or more in the Bitcoin protocol.  For round numbers, let’s assume half of those people are in the U.S., and that one-seventh of those are above a more signif­i­cant threshold like $2500.  That’s just 500,000 U.S. citizens with a meaningful amount of Bitcoin.  And of those, what percentage actually under­stand and care about Bitcoin to the point where they would fight for it?  Let’s be generous and say 20%.

There are approx­i­mately 100,000 Bitcoiners in the United States.  This means that just to get to “intran­si­gent minority” levels, we need a 100x increase.  This is why adoption dominates all other prior­i­ties for Bitcoin.

Bitcoiners have already knocked out so many poten­tial attack vectors and handled so much FUD that there’s not much downside risk.

Another concept Taleb refer­ences throughout the five volumes of his Incerto is: Protect Your Downside.  Bitcoiners have already knocked out so many poten­tial attack vectors and handled so much FUD that there’s not much downside risk left for Bitcoin.  But there is some, whether you handicap it at sub‑1%, sub-10%, or more.  And by far the most threat­ening attack vector, in my opinion, would be a concerted effort of the U.S. govern­ment at many levels attempting to stamp out Bitcoin in an effort to maintain dollar hegemony across the globe.

Let’s be clear: Bitcoin would survive even the most concerted and vicious attack by the U.S. govern­ment.  It might even thrive, Antifragile-style (another Taleb book), with people around the globe snapping up sats en masse as they witness the erstwhile hegemon lash out.  But it could also play out differ­ently, with a massive drop in network activity and value, thousands of individual lives irreparably disrupted, and the delay of our bright orange future by decades or longer.

This, to me, is unaccept­able.  That is why I have dedicated my life to recruiting the other 99% of our intran­si­gent Bitcoiner minority here in the United States.  There are 100,000 of us already.  Help us recruit the other 9.9 million.

Cory Klipp­sten talks about the intran­si­gent minority on the Stephan Livera podcast.
This blog offers thoughts and opinions on Bitcoin from the Swan Bitcoin team and friends. Swan Bitcoin is the easiest way to buy Bitcoin using your bank account automatically every week, month, or paycheck, starting with as little as $10. Sign up or learn more here.

Cory Klippsten

Founder and CEO of SwanBitcoin.com, the best way to buy Bitcoin, and of GiveBitcoin.io, the best way to onboard someone new into Bitcoin.

More from Swan Signal

Thoughts on Bitcoin from the Swan team and friends.

Raoul Pal and Vijay Boyapati: Swan Signal Live E30

By Brady Swenson

Raoul Pal, founder and CEO of Real Vision and the Global Macro Investors, joins Vijay Boyapati, author of “The Bullish Case for Bitcoin”. Most of the conver­sa­tion focuses on building our new finan­cial infra­struc­ture on top of Bitcoin and why Vijay Boyapati doesn’t believe that will be built via Ethereum. But Raoul and Vijay also discuss the history of fiat, defla­tion, Bitcoin vs Ethereum, risks to Bitcoin, and price manip­u­la­tion. As always Brady Swenson, Swan Head of Educa­tion, hosts the lively discus­sion.

Read More

Founder of The Investors Podcast Network, Preston Pysh, and author of Why Buy Bitcoin, Andy Edstrom, reunite their incred­ible camaraderie to discuss Micros­trategy adding even more Bitcoin to their balance sheet. They disucss how Michael Saylor’s made these purchase, why he made the purchases, and why this was such an impor­tant devel­op­ment for Bitcoin. As always Brady Swenson, Swan Bitcoin’s Head of Educa­tion, hosts the lively discus­sion.

Read More

On Bitcoin’s UX

By Gigi

There is an ongoing discus­sion about the quality of Bitcoin’s user experi­ence. Bitcoin UX is evolving just like the Internet.

Read More

Join our mailing list to receive new articles from the Swan Signal

Swan Bitcoin
© 2020 Swan Bitcoin
© 2020 Swan Bitcoin
Swan Bitcoin does not provide any investment, financial, tax, legal or other professional advice. We recommend that you consult with financial and tax advisors to understand the risks and consequences of buying, selling and holding Bitcoin.